Solution LISS.C21 Robert Beezer
We begin with a relation of linear dependence using unknown scalars $a$ and $b$. We wish to know if these scalars must both be zero. Recall that the zero vector in $C$ is $(-1,\,-1)$ and that the definitions of vector addition and scalar multiplication in Example CVS are not what we might expect. \begin{align*} \zerovector &=(-1,\,-1)\\ &=a(0,\,2) +b(2,\,8)&&\knowl{./knowls/definition.RLD.knowl}{\text{Definition RLD}}\\ &=(0a+a-1,\,2a+a-1) + (2b+b-1,\,8b+b-1)&&\knowl{./knowls/example.CVS.knowl}{\text{Example CVS}}\\ &=(a-1,\,3a-1) + (3b-1,\,9b-1)\\ &=(a-1+3b-1+1,\,3a-1+9b-1+1)&&\knowl{./knowls/example.CVS.knowl}{\text{Example CVS}}\\ &=(a+3b-1,\,3a+9b-1)\\ \end{align*} From this we obtain two equalities, which can be converted to a homogeneous system of equations, \begin{align*} -1&=a+3b-1&a+3b&=0\\ -1&=3a+9b-1&3a+9b&=0 \end{align*} This homogeneous system has a singular coefficient matrix, and so has more than just the trivial solution (Definition NM). Any nontrivial solution will give us a nontrivial relation of linear dependence on $S$. So $S$ is linearly dependent (Definition LI).